Updated as of August 2026
Tracking President Trump's Promises to the American People
In his 2024 Presidential campaign, Donald Trump made 54 clear, definite promises, which are all graded below.
- Tracked
- 54 promises
- Issue areas
- 8
The Scorecard
41%
kept in full: 22 of 54 tracked promises.
17%
still in progress: 9 of 54.
13%
not delivered at all: 7 of 54.
The rest sit in between: 12 are watered down or compromised promises, and 4 were stopped in court.
This is as of August 2026, 19 months into President Trump's second term.
Every promise, sized by verdict. Select a band to filter the list below.
54 of 54
Border & Immigration
7- Promise Kept
Border & Immigration
Seal the southern border and shut down the Biden-era crossing surge
What he said
“On day one, I will seal the border.”
Video: "On day one I will seal the border and stop the invasion" (2024 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 1: "SEAL THE BORDER, AND STOP THE MIGRANT INVASION" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Southwest border encounters fell to their lowest sustained level in decades within months of inauguration. Three things drove it: a national emergency declared on January 20, 2025, his first day in office, an order shutting off asylum claims for anyone crossing between ports of entry, and active-duty troops sent to the border.
SourcesDHS: 14 straight months of zero releases at the borderCBP Nationwide Encounters dataCBP Southwest Land Border Encounters
- In Progress
Border & Immigration
Carry out the largest deportation operation in American history
What he said
“To keep our families safe, the Republican platform promises to launch the largest deportation operation in the history of our country.”
Fox News: "the largest mass deportation in the history of our country" (2024 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 2: "CARRY OUT THE LARGEST DEPORTATION OPERATION IN AMERICAN HISTORY" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Interior arrests rose sharply and the 2025 budget bill paid for a large expansion of detention beds and deportation flights. Removals have climbed hard: 248,739 in FY2024, 319,980 in FY2025, and 356,389 by mid-July of FY2026. That is about 1,255 people a day, which puts the full year near 460,000.
The catch is the word largest. The Obama years still hold the record, and this pace comes close to it without clearly passing it, so the promise is being kept in substance and not yet in the superlative he used.
SourcesCBS News: "the largest deportation operation in the history of our country" (RNC, July 2024)TRAC: Trump administration record on detention and removalsICE Enforcement and Removal Statistics
- Promise Kept
Border & Immigration
Reinstate Remain in Mexico and end catch-and-release
What he said
“We will reinstate my “Remain in Mexico” policy.”
Video: "We will reinstate my 'Remain in Mexico' policy" (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Biden had ended both policies. Trump restored them by executive action in the first days of the term. People who cross the southern border seeking asylum are again sent back across it to wait for their immigration hearings, instead of being released into the country with a future court date.
SourcesDHS: reinstating the Migrant Protection ProtocolsAmerican Immigration Council: what the Migrant Protection Protocols areDHS press releases
- Blocked
Border & Immigration
End automatic birthright citizenship for children of illegal aliens
What he said
“On Day One of my new term in office, I will sign an executive order making clear to federal agencies that, under the correct interpretation of the law, going forward the future children of illegal aliens will not receive automatic U.S. citizenship.”
NBC News: Trump's day-one order to end birthright citizenship (May 30, 2023)
Agenda47: "Day One Executive Order Ending Citizenship for Children of Illegals and Outlawing Birth Tourism" (2023 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump signed the order on January 20, 2025, his first day in office, exactly as promised. Federal judges blocked it within days, so it never applied to a single child. On June 30, 2026 the Supreme Court struck it down 6 to 3, ruling that the Fourteenth Amendment grants citizenship to nearly everyone born on American soil and that a president cannot change that with an order.
Trump did what he said he would do and the courts stopped him. That is the difference between Blocked and Not Delivered. Doing it now would take a constitutional amendment: two thirds of both chambers of Congress and three quarters of the states.
SourcesSCOTUSblog: Court strikes down birthright citizenship orderNPR: Ruling on constitutional grounds
- In Progress
Border & Immigration
Finish the border wall
What he said
“I will end the illegal immigration crisis by closing our border and finishing the wall, most of which I've already built.”
Video: Trump vows to complete the border wall, RNC Night 4 (July 18, 2024)
Fox: full transcript of the 2024 RNC acceptance speech (July 18, 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform: "We will complete the Border Wall" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A national emergency declared on January 20 put Homeland Security and Defense to work on new barrier, and contracts and land waivers followed. Roughly 80 miles have gone up. That is real construction, and it is a small piece of the job: the southern border runs about 1,950 miles. At the pace so far, finishing it is the work of several more years, so the promise is underway rather than done.
SourcesPolitiFact: projects adding over 80 miles of new barrierTIME: what is the status of Trump's border wallCBP border infrastructure updates
- Promise Kept
Border & Immigration
Restore and expand the travel ban on high-risk countries
What he said
“We will seal our border and bring back the travel ban.”
TIME: "we will seal our border and bring back the travel ban" (Sept. 20, 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform: "We will bring back the Travel Ban" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The campaign pledge was to "bring back the travel ban" and to bar refugee resettlement from Gaza. A proclamation restricting entry took effect in 2025 and was expanded to 19 countries, up from seven in the first-term version.
SourcesCongressional Research Service: the expanded travel ban effective January 1, 2026American Immigration Council: who the 2025 travel ban affectsPresidential Actions
- Blocked
Border & Immigration
Cut federal funding to sanctuary cities and states
What he said
“We will not make any payments to sanctuary cities or states having cities, because they do everything possible to protect criminals at the expense of American citizens.”
Yahoo News: Trump vows to withhold federal funds from sanctuary cities and states (Jan. 13, 2025 (transition))
Axios: the April 2025 order targeting sanctuary jurisdictions (Apr. 29, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
He moved on this immediately. A day-one order directed the Attorney General and Homeland Security to ensure sanctuary jurisdictions receive no federal funding, and Executive Order 14287 followed on April 28, 2025, requiring a published list of non-cooperating jurisdictions and eligibility checks to keep people in the country illegally from receiving federal benefits. The Justice Department published the list.
The funding cutoff itself did not survive. A federal judge blocked it, holding that ordering agencies to withhold or condition money Congress had already appropriated violates the separation of powers and the Spending Clause, that parts of the order were unconstitutionally vague, and that it violated the Tenth Amendment by trying to force local officials to enforce federal immigration law.
The administration argued to lift the injunction before a Ninth Circuit panel in December 2025. He did what he said he would do and the courts stopped the money from moving, which is Blocked rather than Not Delivered.
SourcesJustice Department: the published list of sanctuary jurisdictionsNBC News: judge blocks the bid to halt federal funding to sanctuary citiesNPR: the executive order and the courts' skepticismNational Constitution Center: sanctuary jurisdictions return to the courts
Legal Immigration
4- Promise Kept
Legal Immigration
Suspend refugee resettlement and cut admissions
What he said
“On Day One of the Trump Presidency, I will suspend refugee admissions, stop the resettlement, and keep the terrorists the hell out of our country.”
PolitiFact: Trump's 2024 campaign promises, including suspending refugee admissions (2024 campaign)
CBS News: Trump's 2024 immigration plan, including suspending refugee admissions and ideological screening (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump suspended the refugee admissions program by executive order on January 20, 2025, his first day in office. A district judge blocked the suspension in February 2025, but the Ninth Circuit overturned that part of the ruling on March 5, 2026, so the freeze on new refugee processing stands. The court did require the government to keep paying for resettlement help already owed to refugees who had arrived. The cap for FY2026 is 7,500 people, the lowest since the program began in 1980.
SourcesPacito v. Trump: Ninth Circuit opinionWRAPS: refugee admissions and arrivals dataIRC: administration suspends refugee resettlement
- Promise Kept
Legal Immigration
Ideologically vet arrivals and deport foreign students who back Hamas
What he said
“We will deport the jihadist sympathizers and revoke the student visas of Hamas supporters.”
Trump vows to revoke student visas and deport "Hamas sympathizers" (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The State Department now reviews the social media accounts of student visa applicants, and it has revoked visas from foreign nationals who took part in campus protests. Individual removals have drawn First Amendment challenges, since the First Amendment protects foreign students present in the United States.
SourcesInside Higher Ed: State Department expands social media screening for student visasTIME: what the new social media screening for student visas requiresPresidents' Alliance: the visa revocation litigationState Dept. visa policy updates
- Promise Kept
Legal Immigration
End the diversity visa lottery
What he said
“I am today starting the process of terminating the diversity lottery program.”
TIME: Trump calls for ending the diversity visa lottery, "I am today starting the process of terminating the diversity lottery program" (Nov. 1, 2017)
Newsweek: his State of the Union demand to scrap the visa lottery and chain migration (Jan. 30, 2018)
PolitiFact: fact-checking his rally description of how the visa lottery works (Dec. 20, 2017)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The 2027 lottery registration was postponed in November 2025 and has never opened. In December 2025, after the Brown University shooting and the killing of an MIT professor, the State Department stopped issuing diversity visas entirely while it reviewed how applicants are screened. As of July 2026 none are being issued and no sign-up window has opened. The lottery is still written into federal law, so this is a shutdown by executive action, and the next president could switch it back on without asking Congress.
SourcesFragomen: USCIS suspends diversity visa approvals pending security reviewEnvoy Global: full suspension of the diversity visa programState Dept.: Diversity Visa Issuance Updated Guidance
- Not Delivered
Legal Immigration
End chain migration and move to a merit-based immigration system
What he said
“A single immigrant can bring in virtually unlimited numbers of distant relatives.”
CNN: what Trump promised to do in a second term (2024 campaign)
ABC News: eight separate occasions on which he attacked chain migration (2017-2018)
Newsweek: fact-checking his repeated State of the Union demands to end chain migration and the visa lottery (Jan. 30, 2018)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Chain migration means family-based immigration. One immigrant gets a green card, sponsors a relative, and years later that relative sponsors relatives of their own. The 1965 immigration act built the system this way, so family ties rather than skills decide who gets in. Trump wanted it cut to spouses and young children, and everyone else scored on skills, education, and English, the way Canada and Australia do it.
About 1.3 million people received green cards in fiscal 2025. Family ties account for roughly two thirds of all legal immigration, including 196,740 through the capped family preference categories he named directly.
None of that has changed. Those categories are written into the Immigration and Nationality Act, which means only Congress can remove them and no executive order can. The RAISE Act, the 2017 bill he endorsed to do exactly this, would have cut the family categories and scored applicants on points. It never received a floor vote, and nothing has replaced it since. The State Department is still issuing these visas every month, on the same schedule as before.
That line, between border enforcement and immigration law, explains a record that looks contradictory. At the border he has enormous unilateral power over who enters and who is removed, and he used it hard. Over green cards issued under a category Congress created, he has almost none. Delivering this one always meant getting a bill through the Senate, and that fight has not been picked.
SourcesState Dept. Visa Bulletin: family preference visas still being issued monthlyDHS Office of Homeland Security Statistics: lawful permanent resident annual flow reportsNewsweek: DHS figures for FY2025 green cards, including 196,740 family preferenceMigration Policy Institute: how the U.S. legal immigration system works
Economy & Taxes
6- Promise Kept
Economy & Taxes
Make the Trump tax cuts permanent and stop the largest tax hike in history
What he said
“The fifth pillar of my plan is to make the Trump tax cuts permanent. They are massive tax cuts, the biggest ever, permanent.”
C-SPAN: Trump vows to make the 2017 tax cuts permanent (Sept. 5, 2024)
CNBC: for months he said he would make the expiring 2017 provisions permanent (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The 2025 budget law made the expiring individual rates and the larger standard deduction permanent, and let businesses write off equipment purchases in full in the year they buy them. The Congressional Budget Office puts the cost at roughly $4.6 trillion in added debt over a decade.
SourcesEconomic Club of New York: full transcript of the September 5, 2024 addressWays and Means: hearing on making the Trump tax cuts permanentIRS: One Big Beautiful Bill provisions (Public Law 119-21)
- Watered Down
Economy & Taxes
No tax on tips
What he said
“We are going to not charge taxes on tips.”
CNN: Las Vegas rally: "we are going to not charge taxes on tips" (June 9, 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 6: "LARGE TAX CUTS FOR WORKERS, AND NO TAX ON TIPS!" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
It passed in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act as a deduction, not an exemption. Up to $25,000 of tip income comes off your taxable income, it phases out for higher earners, and it expires after 2028. Tips are still income and still taxed above the cap.
Here is what that is worth in a paycheck. Take a server on $80,000 a year with $30,000 of it in tips, filing single. Under the 2025 brackets they owed about $9,000 in federal income tax. The deduction takes $25,000 off their taxable income and the bill falls to about $4,500. That is roughly $4,600 they keep, just under $400 a month, on the same wages as before. For a working family that is a car payment. Anyone calling this symbolic has not run the numbers.
Two things keep it short of the promise. The cap is $25,000, so the last $5,000 of tips in this example is still taxed. And this is an income tax deduction only: Social Security and Medicare tax, 7.65%, still comes out of every tipped dollar. It also expires after 2028 unless Congress renews it.
SourcesFederal Register: final rules defining qualified tips and the tipped occupations listCato Institute: the new income tax deductions for tips and overtimeIRS: how to take advantage of no tax on tips and overtime
- Watered Down
Economy & Taxes
No tax on overtime pay
What he said
“As part of our additional tax cuts, we will end all taxes on overtime.”
ABC News: Tucson rally: "we will end all taxes on overtime" (Sept. 12, 2024)
Axios: Trump pledges to eliminate taxes on overtime pay (Sept. 13, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The pledge was to end "all taxes" on overtime, which would cover income and payroll tax. What passed covers only the premium half of time-and-a-half, caps the deduction at $12,500 (or $25,000 filing jointly), phases out above $150,000 of income, and expires after 2028. Payroll tax still applies to all of it.
Here is what that is worth. Take someone on $80,000 a year working five hours of overtime a week. That is about $38.50 an hour, so time-and-a-half pays $57.70 and a year of it comes to roughly $15,000. The deduction only covers the premium half, the extra $19.20 an hour, which is about $5,000. In the 22% bracket that is around $1,100 back, close to $90 a month. Real money for a shift worker.
It is also a long way from ending all taxes on overtime. Two thirds of that $15,000 is still taxed, payroll tax applies to every dollar of it, and the deduction expires after 2028.
SourcesCNBC: IRS clarifies the no-tax-on-overtime deduction rulesCato Institute: the new income tax deductions for tips and overtimeIRS: how to take advantage of no tax on tips and overtime
- Watered Down
Economy & Taxes
No tax on Social Security benefits for seniors
What he said
“SENIORS SHOULD NOT PAY TAX ON SOCIAL SECURITY!”
Washington Times: "SENIORS SHOULD NOT PAY TAX ON SOCIAL SECURITY!" (July 31, 2024)
CRFB: Trump's suggestion to end taxation of Social Security benefits (July 31, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Seniors 65 and over received a temporary $6,000 enhanced deduction with income limits, running 2025-2028. The law made no change to how Social Security benefits are taxed. Beneficiaries under 65, including survivors, dependents, and disabled workers, get nothing from it.
SourcesIRS: One Big Beautiful Bill provisions for individuals and workersSSA benefit taxation rules
- Not Delivered
Economy & Taxes
Bring down prices starting on day one
What he said
“Starting on day one, we will end inflation and make America affordable again.”
CNN: Trump pledged to bring down food prices on day one (Aug. 9, 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 3: "END INFLATION, AND MAKE AMERICA AFFORDABLE AGAIN" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Consumer prices did not fall. Between January 2025 and June 2026 groceries rose 3.4%, with beef up 12%, coffee up 13%, and fresh vegetables up 9.9%. Energy has risen 13.1%, electricity 8.3%, gasoline 15.2%. Estimates put the added cost at roughly $2,120 per household in 2025, and about $950 for the bottom fifth of earners, more than 5% of their income. Eggs are cheaper than at inauguration; almost nothing else is.
Against Biden the record is much better. Prices rose 21.4% in total across Biden's four years. Inflation, meaning how much higher prices were than twelve months earlier, peaked at 9.1% in June 2022, the fastest rate since 1981. Under Trump that same twelve-month rate was 3.4% in July 2026, with core inflation, which strips out food and fuel, at 2.5%, and the consumer price index up about 4.8% in total through April 2026 against 10.5% over the same stretch of Biden's term. That is about half the pace. It is still a rising price level, and the promise was to bring prices down on day one, not to raise them more slowly.
SourcesBLS Consumer Price Index Summary, July 2026FactCheck.org: Biden's final numbers (21.4% cumulative CPI, Jan. 2021 to Jan. 2025)Texas A&M PERC: inflation, real wages, and unemployment through February 2026CNBC: July 2026 CPI reportCNN fact check: eggs are cheaper, "everything else" is not
- Promise Kept
Economy & Taxes
Protect Social Security and Medicare with no cuts
What he said
“I will not lay a finger on Medicare or Social Security.”
Scripps News: Trump vows not to cut Social Security or Medicare (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Benefit checks were not cut. Nobody on Social Security or Medicare is receiving less money than they were, and no legislation reducing benefit levels has passed. On the promise as most voters heard it, President Trump kept his word.
Two things did change, and a reader should weigh them. The administration cut funding and staffing at the Social Security Administration starting in February 2025, which does not touch benefit amounts but does make the agency slower to reach. And the 2025 budget law ended Medicare eligibility for certain lawfully present immigrants, which is a cut for the people in that group even though it leaves everyone else untouched.
Grading the pledge as stated, benefits are intact. Grading it as an absolute guarantee that nothing about either program would be touched, the record is more mixed than the slogan.
SourcesPolitiFact: no direct Social Security or Medicare benefit cuts under TrumpSocial Security AdministrationCongressional Budget Office: budget and program topics
Trade
8- Watered Down
Trade
Impose reciprocal tariffs and a baseline tariff on foreign goods
What he said
“Whatever countries charge the United States, we will charge them.”
Agenda47: "Cementing Fair and Reciprocal Trade with the Trump Reciprocal Trade Act" (2023 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform: passage of the "Trump Reciprocal Trade Act" (July 2024)
White House: "whatever countries charge the United States, we will charge them" (Feb. 13, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Reciprocal tariffs were imposed in April 2025 and ran for ten months. On February 20, 2026 the Supreme Court held 6-3 in Learning Resources v. Trump that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorize tariffs, because the taxing power belongs to Congress. Importers who had already paid became entitled to refunds, estimated at around $175 billion. The tariffs did not go away, they were re-imposed under different legal authority. Within hours the White House put a temporary 10% global tariff in place under Section 122 of the Trade Act, and when that expired on July 24, 2026 it was replaced with a tariff issued under Section 301. What did not survive is the reciprocal architecture itself, the country-by-country matching of foreign rates that gave the promise its name.
SourcesLearning Resources, Inc. v. Trump: slip opinionGlobal Trade Alert: from IEEPA to Section 122, what changed on Feb. 20, 2026White & Case: U.S. terminates IEEPA tariffs
- Promise Kept
Trade
Impose a 10-20% baseline tariff on all foreign imports
What he said
“I call it a ring around the country. We have a ring around the country.”
CRFB: Trump's universal baseline tariff proposal (10-20%) (2024 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform: "baseline Tariffs on Foreign-made goods" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A 10% universal baseline took effect in April 2025 at the low end of the promised range. The law it rests on has been swapped twice, from emergency economic powers to Section 122 of the Trade Act to Section 301, but a baseline tariff on nearly all imports has been in force continuously and stands at 10% today, with 12.5% for a 46-economy list. The average effective rate is 8.9%, down from a 16.5% peak but the highest since the 1970s.
SourcesTax Foundation tariff tracker: current rates and effective averageCRS: Supreme Court rules against IEEPA tariffs
- Watered Down
Trade
Put a 60% tariff on Chinese goods
What he said
“Maybe it's going to be more than that.”
CRFB: Trump's promised 60% tariff on Chinese imports (2024 campaign)
CNBC: Trump floats "more than" 60% tariffs on Chinese imports, Sunday Morning Futures (Feb. 4, 2024)
Bloomberg: Trump floats a Chinese goods tariff of more than 60% if elected (Feb. 4, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Rates on China reached 145% during the spring 2025 escalation, well past the promised 60%, then fell to 30% under the truce negotiated in Geneva and announced on May 12, 2025. After the Supreme Court voided the emergency-powers tariffs, the administration rebuilt the same rates out of older trade laws, Section 301 and Section 232. China's average effective rate now sits near 31.6%, roughly half the promised level, though individual goods such as Chinese steel can carry 10% baseline plus 25% Section 301 plus 50% Section 232.
SourcesTax Foundation tariff tracker: rates by country and authorityPolitiFact: 145% rate, then Supreme Court restriction
- Not Delivered
Trade
Foreign countries, not American consumers, will pay for the tariffs
What he said
“It's not going to be a cost to you, it's a cost to another country.”
FactCheck.org: "It's not going to be a cost to you. It's going to be a cost to another country" (Sept. 2024)
FactCheck.org: Trump's agenda on tariffs, and his repeated claim that foreign countries pay them (Nov. 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A tariff is collected at the border from the American company importing the goods, not from the foreign company selling them, and the money goes to the U.S. Treasury. Whoever ultimately absorbs it, the check is written by an American business.
Who ultimately absorbs that cost is the part worth arguing about, and the evidence runs one way. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that American consumers and businesses bore close to 90% of the 2025 tariffs, with foreign exporters absorbing about 6% over the first eight months of the year. A separate paper by Federal Reserve and Columbia University economists put the American share at 94%. Fed researchers tracking shelf prices found close to dollar-for-dollar pass-through: when a tariff raised a retailer's cost by $1, the retail price rose by about $1 within seven months. Core goods prices ran roughly 3.1% higher as a result, and the Tax Foundation put the 2025 cost at about $1,000 per household.
The administration has publicly disputed the New York Fed's analysis. On the specific claim graded here, that foreign countries and not American consumers would pay, the available measurements point the other way.
SourcesCBS News: New York Fed finds U.S. consumers and businesses paid nearly 90% of 2025 tariffsFortune: Federal Reserve researchers find close to full pass-through to consumersRetail Dive: U.S. companies and consumers bear 90% of tariff costsPIIE: Who is paying for Trump's tariffs?CBP tariff collections
- Not Delivered
Trade
Use tariff revenue to replace the federal income tax
What he said
“Yeah, sure, but why not?”
CNBC: Trump doubles down on replacing income taxes with tariffs in the Joe Rogan interview (Oct. 26, 2024)
CNN: Trump wants to abolish the IRS and replace it with tariffs (2024-2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The External Revenue Service was announced and customs receipts hit record levels, but the arithmetic never worked: individual income tax raised $2.43 trillion in 2024 against $77 billion in tariffs, a factor of about 32. No repeal proposal was introduced, the income tax is fully intact, and the February 2026 Supreme Court ruling voided the tariffs that were supposed to fund the swap.
SourcesTax Foundation: analysis of the 2024 Trump tax plan, including the tariff-for-income-tax swapTreasury Monthly Statement
- In Progress
Trade
Bring manufacturing jobs back to America
What he said
“Under my leadership, we're going to take other countries' jobs.”
CBS News: Savannah economic speech on a "manufacturing renaissance" (Sept. 24, 2024)
NPR: the Savannah economic speech on taking other countries' jobs (Sept. 24, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Chipmakers, drugmakers, and steel producers announced large new U.S. plants, and the promised 15% corporate tax rate for companies that make their products in the United States was enacted, along with full write-offs for new equipment. Manufacturing payroll employment has been roughly flat since inauguration; the announced facilities carry multi-year construction timelines.
SourcesWashington Examiner: the 15% corporate rate for domestic manufacturersBLS manufacturing employment
- In Progress
Trade
Revoke China's most-favored-nation trade status
What he said
“We will revoke China's Most Favored Nation trade status and adopt a four-year plan to phase out all Chinese imports of essential goods.”
Foreign Policy: Trump's threat to revoke China's permanent normal trade relations, explained (2024 campaign)
Agenda47: the America First trade platform for a second term (2023 campaign)
Agenda47: "President Trump's New Trade Plan to Protect American Workers" (2023 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A presidential memo directed the trade and commerce agencies to assess legislative proposals, bipartisan bills were introduced, and the International Trade Commission opened a probe into the effects of revocation in February 2026. Most-favored-nation status, formally called permanent normal trade relations, can only be repealed by Congress, and no floor vote has been held.
SourcesPolitiFact: no four-year plan to phase out Chinese imports has been releasedPerkins Coie: trade and national security policy in the second termFox News: GOP leaders move to revoke China's most-favored-nation status
- Promise Kept
Trade
Keep the U.S. dollar as the world's reserve currency
What he said
“You leave the dollar, you're not doing business with the United States because we're going to put 100 percent tariff on your goods.”
Axios: Trump threatens 100% tariffs on BRICS countries that move away from the dollar (Nov. 30, 2024)
The Hill: renewing the threat against countries moving off the dollar (2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The dollar is still the world's reserve currency. No BRICS currency exists, none has been launched, and India, a founding member, publicly rejected the idea.
President Trump made the threat repeatedly: at a September 2024 rally, again on November 30 after the election, and on Truth Social after taking office, demanding a commitment that these countries would neither create a BRICS currency nor back any other currency to replace the dollar, on pain of 100% tariffs.
How much of the outcome he caused is not measurable. BRICS members were divided on a common currency well before the threats, and economists argued the tariffs would have damaged the U.S. as much as the targets. What can be said is that the thing he promised to prevent has not happened, and he never had to impose the tariff.
SourcesFortune: BRICS, the dollar, and the tariff threatANU Centre for Applied Macroeconomic Analysis: projected effects of the threatened tariffs
Energy
3- Watered Down
Energy
Drill, baby, drill: unleash American energy and cut energy prices in half
What he said
“If you vote for me, I will cut your energy and electricity prices in half within 12 months.”
2024 Republican Party Platform: "We will DRILL, BABY, DRILL and we will become Energy Independent" (July 2024)
Newsweek: the pledge to halve energy prices, repeated upwards of a dozen times on the trail (Sept. 2024)
The Inaugural Address: "drill, baby, drill" (Jan. 20, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Federal leasing, permitting, and liquefied natural gas export approvals were reopened on January 20, 2025, his first day in office.
On production he delivered outright. U.S. crude oil output averaged a record 13.6 million barrels a day in 2025, breaking the 13.2 million record set in 2024, which was itself the highest any country had ever produced. American output ran about 40% ahead of Russia and Saudi Arabia, the next two largest producers. The Energy Information Administration expects roughly 13.5 million a day in 2026 and 14.2 million by 2027.
The half of the promise that failed is the price half. He pledged to cut energy costs in half within twelve months and that did not happen. Oil fell roughly 20% across 2025, but the cause was OPEC, the cartel of oil-exporting countries, raising output into an oversupplied world market, not American drilling. When prices dropped below what it costs to pull a barrel out of the ground, U.S. drilling slowed down. Record production and a halving of your energy bill are two different promises, and only one of them landed.
SourcesEIA: U.S. crude oil production rose in 2025, setting a new recordEIA: the United States produced more crude oil than any other country in 2025EIA energy prices and production data
- Promise Kept
Energy
End the electric vehicle mandate
What he said
“I will END the Electric Vehicle Mandate on Day One.”
"I will END the Electric Vehicle Mandate on Day One" (RNC address) (July 18, 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 15: "CANCEL THE ELECTRIC VEHICLE MANDATE AND CUT COSTLY REGULATIONS" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump ordered the rollback on January 20, 2025, his first day in office, but the regulation itself took longer. The Environmental Protection Agency proposed repealing the tailpipe rules in July 2025, and the repeal was published in the Federal Register on February 18, 2026, stripping out the greenhouse gas standards for new light-, medium-, and heavy-duty vehicles.
The purchase subsidies went faster. The 2025 budget law ended the $7,500 credit for a new electric vehicle and the $4,000 used-car credit on September 30, 2025. The waiver authority that let California set its own rules requiring electric sales was revoked as well.
Kept, with one honest caveat about timing: the mandate was promised gone on day one and the rule was not actually off the books for another thirteen months.
SourcesIRS: clean vehicle tax credits and their terminationCoastal Review: EPA eliminates emission standards for new vehiclesEPA regulatory actions
- Promise Kept
Energy
Withdraw from the Paris climate agreement
What he said
“I'm immediately withdrawing from the unfair, one-sided Paris climate accord rip-off.”
CNN: what Trump promised to do in a second term (2024 campaign)
E&E News / POLITICO: the campaign said in July 2024 he would withdraw from the Paris accord a second time (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Signed on January 20, 2025, his first day in office, as Executive Order 14162, for the second time, with the United Nations ambassador directed to file formal notice immediately and climate finance commitments rescinded. The United States now sits outside the agreement alongside Iran, Libya, and Yemen.
SourcesExecutive Order 14162, Putting America First in International Environmental AgreementsCRS: U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement, process and effects
Government Reform
5- Watered Down
Government Reform
Create a government efficiency commission and cut $2 trillion in spending
What he said
“I will create a government efficiency commission tasked with conducting a complete financial and performance audit of the entire federal government and making recommendations for drastic reforms.”
NPR: the $2 trillion DOGE target (Oct. 27, 2024)
NPR: Trump taps Musk to lead a Department of Government Efficiency (Nov. 12, 2024)
Government Executive: Trump vows to establish an efficiency commission with Elon Musk at the helm (Sept. 5, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The Department of Government Efficiency, known as DOGE, started immediately and did cut federal headcount and cancel contracts, then stopped operating as a centralized entity in November 2025 and reached its mandated expiration on July 4, 2026. Its dashboard claimed roughly $215 billion in savings, a figure independent analysts disputed and about a tenth of the target, and total federal outlays did not fall. No closing report was published. The $2 trillion figure was Elon Musk's, floated at the Madison Square Garden rally days before the election; he later called it a best case and revised the goal to $1 trillion before departing.
SourcesDOGE: formation, claimed savings, and July 2026 shutdownCBO Monthly Budget Review
- Promise Kept
Government Reform
Restore Schedule F and remove entrenched bureaucrats
What he said
“First, I will immediately re-issue my 2020 Executive Order restoring the President's authority to remove rogue bureaucrats.”
Agenda47: Plan to Dismantle the Deep State (item one: re-issue Schedule F) (2023 campaign)
NBC News: dismantling the "deep state" as a central plank of the 2024 bid, with Schedule F as point one (2023-2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The 2020 executive order was re-issued and finalized as Schedule Policy/Career, reclassifying policy-influencing career positions as at-will, and agencies began using it. Federal employee unions have challenged it in court.
SourcesFinal rule: Improving Performance, Accountability and Responsiveness in the Civil Service (91 FR, Feb. 6, 2026)OPM: Schedule Policy/Career hiring authority
- Watered Down
Government Reform
Close the Department of Education and send education back to the states
What he said
“One thing I'll be doing very early in the administration is closing up the Department of Education in Washington, D.C., and sending all education and education work it needs back to the states.”
Video: "closing up the Department of Education" and sending it back to the states (Sept. 2023 campaign video)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Roughly half the department's staff were laid off, and student loan servicing and several other programs were handed to other agencies. Lower courts ordered the staff reinstated, but the Supreme Court cleared the way for the layoffs 6-3 in McMahon v. New York in July 2025, with the underlying case still live. Abolishing the department requires an act of Congress; no such bill has passed, and it continues to operate, retaining Title I funding, Pell grants, and disability programs.
SourcesCNBC: executive order to dismantle the Department of EducationSCOTUSblog: Court clears the way to shrink the Education DepartmentED press releases
- Blocked
Government Reform
Secure elections with voter ID, paper ballots, and proof of citizenship
What he said
“I will once and for all secure our elections. We're going to go to paper ballots. We're going to have same-day voting, voter ID.”
CNN fact check: what Trump keeps saying about paper ballots, same-day voting, and voter ID (Oct. 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 19: "SECURE OUR ELECTIONS, INCLUDING SAME DAY VOTING, VOTER ID" (July 2024)
Poynter: pressing governors on proof of citizenship, voter ID, and paper ballots (2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump signed an elections executive order on March 25, 2025 and a second one, Executive Order 14399, on March 31, 2026. Together they ordered documentary proof of citizenship for federal voter registration, tighter mail ballot deadlines, and federal pressure on states that did not comply.
The courts took the center of it apart. Judge Denise Casper ruled that the proof-of-citizenship requirement exceeded presidential authority and violated the separation of powers, because setting election rules belongs to Congress and the states, and she made that permanent in June 2026. Two other federal judges blocked it as well, one of them ruling for nineteen states that had sued.
Not all of it fell. The Supreme Court allowed parts of the mail-in voting order to take effect 6-3 ahead of the November midterms, letting Homeland Security build a federal citizenship list to share with states and letting the Attorney General prioritize prosecutions of state election officials.
He acted, and acted twice. The signature piece was struck down, which is why this is Blocked rather than Not Delivered. Voter ID and paper ballots are set by states, and no president can order them into place.
SourcesWhite House: Ensuring Citizenship Verification and Integrity in Federal ElectionsPBS: federal judge bars the proof of citizenship requirementABC News: judge permanently blocks the proof of citizenship orderABC News: Supreme Court allows parts of the mail-in voting order
- In Progress
Government Reform
Cut ten federal regulations for every new one
What he said
“To stop this onslaught and lower prices I am pledging today that in my second term we will eliminate a minimum of 10 old regulations for every one regulation.”
Government Executive: Trump wants ten regulations cut for each new one (Sept. 2024)
Forbes: the ten-out-for-one-in proposal and how it would work (Sept. 6, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
He made the pledge at the Economic Club of New York on September 5, 2024 and signed the order after taking office. It requires agencies to identify at least ten existing rules, regulations, or guidance documents for repeal for every new one they propose.
The order is in force and agencies are working to it. Whether the ratio is being met in practice is the open question, because repealing a rule takes the same notice-and-comment process as writing one, which means months or years and a court challenge at the end of it. Analysts across the spectrum, including the Competitive Enterprise Institute, have questioned whether ten to one is achievable at scale.
The mechanism was delivered exactly as promised. The count is not yet verifiable, which is why this is In Progress rather than Kept.
SourcesSafety+Health: the order directing agencies to cut ten rules per new oneCompetitive Enterprise Institute: can a ten-for-one rule elimination scale?R Street Institute: how ten-to-one is taking shape in financial services
Foreign Policy & Defense
9- Not Delivered
Foreign Policy & Defense
End the war in Ukraine within 24 hours of taking office
What he said
“I'll have that war settled in one day, 24 hours.”
CNN fact check: 53 times he made the 24-hour pledge (2023-2024)
NBC News: Trump vowed to end the Ukraine war in 24 hours (2023-2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The war did not end in 24 hours, and it has not ended. A revised twenty-point peace plan was discussed in December 2025, and a three-day ceasefire announced in May 2026 collapsed within days, with each side blaming the other. Talks remain stuck on Donetsk, roughly three-quarters of which Russia holds, and on security guarantees. He later called the pledge "sarcastic" and "an exaggeration." A database of his public remarks records at least 53 occasions on which he made it in earnest.
SourcesCFR: War in Ukraine conflict trackerState Department briefings
- In Progress
Foreign Policy & Defense
Restore peace in the Middle East and bring the hostages home
What he said
“If the hostages are not released prior to January 20, 2025, the date that I proudly assume Office as President of the United States, there will be ALL HELL TO PAY in the Middle East.”
Axios: Trump warns of "HELL TO PAY" if the Gaza hostages are not released before inauguration (Dec. 2, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A ceasefire was agreed on January 15, 2025, five days before he took office. It was built in three stages: first an exchange of hostages for Palestinian prisoners, then a wider Israeli withdrawal and further releases, then reconstruction. The first stage brought 33 Israeli hostages home.
A broader deal followed in late 2025. Every living hostage was released and Trump signed a peace agreement alongside other leaders. On the hostages, the promise was kept outright.
What is not settled is who governs Gaza now and whether the terms survive contact with that question. Peace in the region is the larger half of the pledge, and it is still being negotiated.
SourcesCouncil on Foreign Relations: guide to the twenty-point Gaza peace dealNPR: Israel and Hamas agree to a Gaza ceasefireAxios: the White House launches phase two of the ceasefireWhite House briefings
- Not Delivered
Foreign Policy & Defense
Start no new wars and end the era of endless foreign intervention
What he said
“I will keep us out of new wars. I'm the only president in generations who didn't start one.”
CNN fact check: he promised it repeatedly (2024 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 8: "PREVENT WORLD WAR THREE" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The United States struck Iran's nuclear sites in June 2025, then fought a 40-day war alongside Israel from February 28 to April 8, 2026, opening with a strike that killed Iran's supreme leader. That ceasefire crumbled in July 2026 and strikes resumed. Military action was also ordered in Yemen, Syria, Somalia, Nigeria, and Venezuela. None was authorized by Congress. In a June 2026 NBC interview the President said he had never guaranteed no new wars and that as a candidate he "didn't promise anything," a claim contradicted by the campaign record.
SourcesBritannica: 2026 Iran warCNN: US-Iran ceasefire crumbles as fresh strikes hit the regionNPR: Trump on Iran and the no-new-wars pledge
- In Progress
Foreign Policy & Defense
Iran will never be allowed to have a nuclear weapon
What he said
“Iran can't have a nuclear weapon.”
Washington Examiner: Iran and the nuclear pledge as a fixture of the 2024 stump speech (2024 campaign)
C-SPAN: "Iran will never have a nuclear weapon" (restated in office) (White House remarks)
RFE/RL: signing the maximum pressure memo, "Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon" (restated in office, not a campaign receipt) (Feb. 4, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Iran held 440.9 kg of uranium enriched to 60% when B-2s struck Fordow, Natanz, and Esfahan on June 21, 2025. Iran then stopped cooperating, and inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency lost track of where much of that uranium went. The Cairo Agreement restored inspection procedures in September 2025; Iran terminated it that November. A second joint campaign with Israel ran from February 28 to a Pakistan-brokered ceasefire on April 8, 2026, and a June memorandum set a 60-day negotiating framework. Limited inspections have resumed at some sites, but the IAEA still cannot access the enrichment facilities and cannot account for the stockpile. The President has said Iran is denuclearized and also that Iran "can change their mind." Absent verification, the promise is not closed.
SourcesISIS: analysis of IAEA Iran verification and safeguards reports, June 2026House of Commons Library: US-Iran ceasefire and nuclear talks in 2026NPR: dispute widens over Iran nuclear inspections
- Promise Kept
Foreign Policy & Defense
Restore maximum pressure sanctions on Iran
What he said
“We will once again enforce the most aggressive possible sanctions, drive Iranian oil exports to zero, and diminish the regime's capacity to fund terror.”
Times of Israel: Trump plans to renew the maximum pressure strategy (Nov. 8, 2024)
Arms Control Association: Trump's stated intent to return to maximum pressure on Iran (Dec. 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Maximum pressure was reimposed by memorandum on February 4, 2025, with the stated aim of driving Iranian oil exports to zero, and reaching shipping, insurance, and port operators handling that trade.
SourcesNSPM-2, Imposing Maximum Pressure on the Government of IranTreasury OFAC actions
- Promise Kept
Foreign Policy & Defense
Designate the drug cartels as foreign terrorist organizations and treat them like ISIS
What he said
“When I am President, it will be the policy of the United States to take down the cartels just as we took down ISIS and the ISIS caliphate.”
PolitiFact: the promise to designate cartels as terrorist organizations (2023 campaign)
Agenda47: "President Donald J. Trump Declares War on Cartels" (2023 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A day-one executive order directed the designations, and on February 20, 2025 the State Department designated eight groups (six Mexican cartels, Tren de Aragua, and MS-13), unlocking sanctions and authorities since used against trafficking networks.
SourcesPBS: eight Latin American cartels designated as foreign terrorist organizationsAS/COA: which cartels and groups were designatedState Dept. FTO list
- In Progress
Foreign Policy & Defense
Build an Iron Dome style missile defense shield over the United States
What he said
“We will build an Iron Dome over our country, a state-of-the-art missile defense shield, and it's all made in the USA.”
ABC News: Trump wants a US Iron Dome the military hasn't asked for, a regular rally line through 2024 (2024 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform: "a great Iron Dome missile defense shield over our entire country" (July 2024)
TIME: Trump's Golden Dome, what to know (May 21, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
On the campaign trail he called it an Iron Dome for America, after the Israeli system that shoots down short-range rockets. In office the project was renamed Golden Dome and formally announced on May 21, 2025.
Funding so far is $25 billion in the tax bill against a stated price tag of $175 billion over three years, and he said it should be fully operational before his term ends in 2029. The cost estimates have since moved a long way apart. The program office put the figure at $185 billion in March 2026. Two months later the Congressional Budget Office estimated $1.2 trillion to build, deploy, and run it over twenty years, roughly six times the Pentagon number.
The gap is mostly one component. Interceptors based in space account for about 70% of the acquisition cost in the CBO analysis, and no country has built them at anything like this scale. That layer is what the promise rests on, and it does not exist yet.
The design depends on interceptors based in space, which no country has built at anything like this scale. As of this review nothing has been deployed.
SourcesCongressional Budget Office: cost of a Golden Dome style missile defense, May 2026NPR: CBO puts the Golden Dome at $1.2 trillionCongressional Research Service: the Army and the Golden Dome programCRS defense primer: Golden Dome for America
- Promise Kept
Foreign Policy & Defense
Make NATO allies pay their fair share
What he said
“You don't pay your bills, you get no protection. It's very simple.”
ABC News: Trump's repeated claims about NATO members and defense spending (Feb. 2024)
PIIE: Trump's five percent doctrine and NATO defense spending (2024-2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
During the campaign Trump wanted allies spending at least 3% of their national income on defense. After the election he raised the number to 5%.
Trump got the 5%. At the NATO summit in The Hague on June 25, 2025 the alliance agreed to reach 5% by 2035. Every member signed except Spain, which was granted an exemption. That is more than he asked for as a candidate.
Two things cut against it. The deadline is 2035, a decade away and long after he leaves office. And the 5% is split: at least 3.5% has to be actual military spending, while the remaining 1.5% can be things like roads, cyber defenses, and factories. Counted the strict way, the commitment is 3.5%, not 5%.
SourcesThe Hague Summit Declaration, NATO official textCRS: NATO's June 2025 summit in The Hague
- Promise Kept
Foreign Policy & Defense
Withdraw the United States from the World Health Organization
What he said
“I will again withdraw from the WHO, which stands for We Hide Outbreaks.”
CBS News: the campaign promises Trump made to voters, including leaving the WHO (2024 campaign)
The Hill: reviewing the 2024 campaign promises one year on (2026)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump signed Executive Order 14155 on January 20, 2025, his first day in office, starting the one-year notice the WHO constitution requires. The United States formally left on January 22, 2026, ending its membership, its seat in the organization's governance, and its funding contributions.
This is the second time he ordered it. The first attempt, in 2020, was reversed by the Biden administration before it took effect. This one ran the full clock and completed.
SourcesHHS: fact sheet on the U.S. withdrawal from the World Health OrganizationNPR: the U.S. begins the process of leaving the WHOLawfare: the withdrawal orders from international organizations and treaties
Culture & Rule of Law
12- Promise Kept
Culture & Rule of Law
Pardon the January 6 defendants
What he said
“My first acts as your next President will be to Close the Border, DRILL, BABY, DRILL, and Free the January 6 Hostages being wrongfully imprisoned!”
ABC News: Trump promises to free Jan. 6 defendants on day one (2024 campaign)
Washington Post: making January 6 a cornerstone of the 2024 campaign, including the pardon pledge (Mar. 19, 2024)
NBC News: Trump says again he would "absolutely" pardon Jan. 6 rioters (2024 campaign)
NPR: a review of posts, speeches and interviews found he promised Jan. 6 pardons more than a dozen times (Jan. 4, 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Proclamation 10887, signed on the first day of the term, commuted the sentences of fourteen named individuals to time served and granted full, complete, and unconditional pardons to every other person convicted in connection with January 6, roughly 1,500 in all. That is broader than the campaign's suggestion that violent cases might be excluded.
SourcesFederal Register: Proclamation granting pardons and commutations for January 6 offensesJustice Department: text of the clemency proclamationLawfare: Trump pardons or commutes the terms of all January 6 rioters
- Promise Kept
Culture & Rule of Law
Keep men out of women's sports
What he said
“We will of course keep men out of women's sports.”
Fox News: Trump vows to keep men out of women's sports at Salem, VA rally (Nov. 2, 2024)
Washington Post video: "We will of course keep men out of women's sports" (Nov. 3, 2024)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 17: "KEEP MEN OUT OF WOMEN'S SPORTS" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
An executive order titled "Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports" directed Title IX enforcement against schools allowing male athletes in women's competition, and governing bodies changed their eligibility rules in response. On June 30, 2026 the Supreme Court upheld the Idaho and West Virginia bans, ruling unanimously that they do not violate federal civil rights law and dividing 6-3 on the constitutional question, with Justice Kavanaugh writing that the Constitution and Title IX do not require an overhaul of women's sports.
SourcesChristian Post: the Salem, VA rally pledge, Nov. 2, 2024SCOTUSblog: states may exclude transgender athletes from girls' and women's teamsPresidential Actions
- Not Delivered
Culture & Rule of Law
Make IVF free, paid for by the government or mandated insurance coverage
What he said
“Under the Trump administration your government will pay for, or your insurance company will be mandated to pay for, all costs associated with IVF treatment.”
NBC News: Trump says he wants IVF paid for by the government or mandated insurance coverage (Aug. 29, 2024)
CBS News: the IVF pledge, and Americans still waiting on it (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
The executive order that followed directs agencies to produce policy recommendations for protecting access and reducing out-of-pocket costs. It does not make in vitro fertilization free, mandates nothing of insurers, and appropriates no money. Congressional Republicans rejected a proposal to extend coverage to servicemembers. Costs to patients are essentially unchanged.
SourcesKFF: will the announcement expand access to IVF?CNN: Trump promised no-cost IVF for all, and it is still a long way off
- Promise Kept
Culture & Rule of Law
Declassify the remaining JFK assassination files
What he said
“When I return to the White House, I will declassify and unseal all JFK assassination-related documents. It's been 60 years, time for the American people to know the TRUTH!”
Video: Trump promises to release the last JFK files (Nov. 22, 2024)
Newsweek: he pledged the same declassification in the first term and returned to it on the 2024 trail (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
A January 2025 executive order directed declassification of the JFK, RFK, and MLK files, and roughly 80,000 pages were posted by the National Archives in March 2025. He made the same pledge in his first term and left about 3,000 records redacted; this time the release was far more complete.
SourcesForbes: what he said on the trail about releasing the remaining JFK filesNational Archives JFK CollectionFox News: Trump signs order to declassify the JFK, RFK, and MLK assassination filesWhite House fact sheet: declassification of the JFK, RFK, and MLK files
- Promise Kept
Culture & Rule of Law
Take federal control of Washington, D.C. and clean up crime in the capital
What he said
“We will take over the horribly run capital of our nation in Washington, D.C., and clean it up, renovate it, and rebuild our capital city so that it's no longer a nightmare of murder and crime.”
NBC News: Trump vows a federal takeover of Washington, D.C. (Jan. 2024)
Fox News: he vowed a D.C. takeover multiple times on the 2024 campaign trail (2024 campaign)
2024 Republican Party Platform, promise 11: "REBUILD OUR CITIES, INCLUDING WASHINGTON DC" (July 2024)
What has happened · as of August 2026
On August 11, 2025 President Trump placed the Metropolitan Police Department under direct federal control and deployed an initial 800 National Guard troops, declaring a crime emergency in the capital. He said he would do this repeatedly through 2024 and he did it.
Crime fell over the following year. The FBI reported nearly 15,000 arrests under the operation and overall crime dropped between 2025 and 2026.
How much of that drop the takeover caused is disputed. Violent crime in the District had already fallen to a 30-year low in 2024, before he returned to office, so part of the decline was underway regardless. The Center for American Progress argues the Guard deployments did not reduce urban crime at the cost involved. What is not disputed is that he promised a federal takeover of the capital and delivered one, and that it is now planned to run through January 2029 at an estimated $1.4 billion.
SourcesWashington Post: key moments in the D.C. federal takeoverNewsweek: what one year of D.C. crime data showsNPR: results of the 2025 National Guard deployments were unclearCenter for American Progress: the deployments and urban crime
- Watered Down
Culture & Rule of Law
Cut federal funding for schools pushing critical race theory and gender ideology
What he said
“Cut federal funding for any school or program pushing critical race theory, gender ideology, or other inappropriate racial, sexual, or political content on our children.”
Agenda47: "President Trump's Plan to Protect Children from Left-Wing Gender Insanity" (2023 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump signed the order on January 29, 2025. It bars federal money from K-12 schools teaching critical race theory or what it calls gender ideology, and gave the Education and Defense secretaries 90 days to produce a strategy for ending what the order describes as indoctrination.
The order is real and the strategy was produced. What it cannot do is reach most classrooms. Federal law forbids Washington from dictating curriculum, federal money is only about 8 to 10% of K-12 funding, and there are roughly 13,000 school districts to monitor. The leverage is real in high-poverty districts that depend more heavily on federal dollars and thin almost everywhere else.
The order was delivered in full. The effect on what is taught is far smaller than the promise implied, which is why this is Watered Down rather than Kept.
SourcesThe Hill: order bars federal funds for schools teaching CRT and gender ideologyChalkbeat: can he actually withhold school aid over these lessons?Education Week: the funding threat and the strategy it ordered
- Blocked
Culture & Rule of Law
End federal support for gender transition procedures for minors
What he said
“Cease all programs that promote the concept of sex and gender transition at any age.”
Agenda47: "President Trump's Plan to Protect Children from Left-Wing Gender Insanity" (2023 campaign)
Forbes: what Agenda47 committed him to before inauguration (Jan. 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump signed the order on January 28, 2025. It declared that the federal government would not fund, sponsor, promote, assist, or support gender transition for anyone under 19, and moved to cut off federal money for puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and surgery, along with research and education grants to hospitals and medical schools that provide them.
Families, PFLAG, and GLMA sued within weeks. In February 2025 a federal district court issued a nationwide restraining order barring agencies from withholding federal money on the basis that a provider offers this care to patients under 19.
He signed what he said he would sign, on the timeline he promised, and a court stopped it from taking effect. That is Blocked, not Not Delivered.
SourcesGlobal News: the order restricting gender-affirming care for minorsLambda Legal: federal judge blocks the orderNBC News: families and advocacy groups sue over the orders
- Watered Down
Culture & Rule of Law
Make it federal policy that there are only two sexes, male and female
What he said
“As of today, it will henceforth be the official policy of the United States government that there are only two genders, male and female.”
Agenda47: "President Trump's Plan to Protect Children from Left-Wing Gender Insanity" (2023 campaign)
CNN: the inaugural address line on two genders (Jan. 20, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
President Trump said this in the inaugural address and signed the order the same day. It directs every federal agency to recognize two sexes, bars using gender identity as a basis for federal categorisation, freezes funding for programs the order calls gender ideology, and rescinds the Biden-era guidance that treated gender as distinct from sex. A second order on February 5, 2025 applied it to women's sports.
The declaration stands and agencies are operating under it. Several specific applications are not. In June 2025 a federal court ordered the State Department back to its previous passport policy, including the X marker, while litigation continues. A separate order blocked moving transgender women into men's federal prisons and required medical treatment to continue there.
The Supreme Court did let the military service ban take effect by staying the injunction against it.
The policy was declared exactly as promised. It is not being applied everywhere it was written to apply, which is why this is Watered Down rather than Kept.
SourcesWhite House: Defending Women From Gender Ideology ExtremismHolland & Knight: how the order is being applied across agenciesACLU: Orr v. Trump, the passport marker case
- Watered Down
Culture & Rule of Law
Impose the death penalty on drug dealers and traffickers
What he said
“We're going to be asking everyone who sells drugs, gets caught selling drugs, to receive the death penalty for their heinous acts.”
C-SPAN: Trump calls for the death penalty for drug dealers (2024 campaign)
NPR: the campaign pledge to execute drug dealers, smugglers, and traffickers (May 2023)
What has happened · as of August 2026
He acted on this immediately. A day-one executive order directed the Attorney General to resume federal executions and to seek capital punishment wherever the severity of the crime allows it. Pam Bondi lifted the Biden moratorium on federal executions and, reviving a 2018 policy, told prosecutors to use drug trafficking statutes to pursue the death penalty where they apply.
The promise itself cannot be delivered by executive action. The Supreme Court has held that the death penalty is unconstitutional for crimes that do not result in a death, so selling drugs is not eligible no matter what a president or an attorney general instructs. Changing that requires Congress and then a Supreme Court willing to revisit its own precedent, and neither has happened.
Federal executions have resumed for crimes that do qualify. Nobody has been sentenced to death for selling drugs, and under current law nobody can be.
SourcesDeath Penalty Information Center: the day-one order on capital punishmentJustice Department: restoring and strengthening the federal death penaltyStateline: the death penalty push meets resistance in some red states
- In Progress
Culture & Rule of Law
Sign national concealed carry reciprocity into law
What he said
“I will sign concealed carry reciprocity. Your Second Amendment does not end at the state line.”
ABC News: gun groups expect Trump to act on his concealed carry reciprocity promise (2024 campaign)
American Rifleman: Trump on the NRA and national concealed carry reciprocity (2024 campaign)
What has happened · as of August 2026
This one was never his to sign alone, and he said as much: the pledge was to sign the bill, not to create the policy by order. A president cannot make a Texas carry permit valid in New York by executive action.
The Constitutional Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act cleared the House Judiciary Committee in March 2025 and has been waiting for floor time since. It has not been debated, has not passed the House, and has not reached the Senate. No bill has reached his desk, and there has been no executive action on carry permits.
The bill is alive and moving slowly, so this is In Progress. If the term ends without a floor vote, it becomes Not Delivered.
SourcesPolitiFact: the reciprocity bill's progress in the HousePolitiFact fact check: reciprocity has not been expandedFox News: House Republicans push nationwide concealed carry
- Watered Down
Culture & Rule of Law
Provide universal school choice for every American family
What he said
“I want every parent in America to be empowered to send their child to public, private, charter, or faith-based school of their choice.”
ABC News: the second-term plan for schools, including universal school choice (2024 campaign)
Agenda47 on education: universal school choice, teacher tenure, and curriculum (Sept. 2023)
What has happened · as of August 2026
Something real passed. The 2025 budget law created the Education Freedom Tax Credit, a dollar-for-dollar federal credit of up to $1,700 for donations to organisations that award school scholarships. It is the first national school voucher mechanism of its kind.
It is not universal, and it is not yet operating. The credit does not take effect until January 1, 2027. It works through donations to scholarship organisations rather than giving money directly to families. And it is opt-in by state: 23 states had joined as of late 2025, meaning families in the other 27 get nothing from it, including in some of the largest states.
A capped, delayed, opt-in tax credit is a long way from every parent in America being empowered to choose. Real progress, much smaller than promised.
SourcesDepartment of Education: Education Freedom Tax Credit fact sheetHechinger Report: ten things to know about the new voucher programPolitiFact: the school choice tax credit and what it does not do
- Promise Kept
Culture & Rule of Law
Ban federal agencies from colluding to censor lawful speech
What he said
“I will sign an executive order banning any federal department or agency from colluding with any organization, business, or person, to censor, limit, categorize, or impede the lawful speech of American citizens.”
Agenda47: "President Donald J. Trump, Free Speech Policy Initiative" (2023 campaign)
American Presidency Project: Executive Order 14149, the text of what he signed (Jan. 20, 2025)
What has happened · as of August 2026
He signed it hours after the inaugural address, on January 20, 2025. Executive Order 14149 bars federal employees from acting to limit lawful speech, prohibits taxpayer money being used to do it, and directs the Attorney General to investigate the previous four years of federal contacts with platforms.
The order names what it is reversing: pressure applied to social media companies over COVID-19 claims and over the Hunter Biden laptop story. Several platforms have since dropped or narrowed their fact-checking programs, Meta among them.
This one is Kept on the plainest reading. What the order cannot do is bind private companies, which remain free to moderate as they choose, so the promise reaches government conduct rather than speech online generally.
SourcesBallotpedia: Restoring Freedom of Speech and Ending Federal CensorshipFirst Amendment Encyclopedia: what the order does and does not reachLawfare: analysis of the speech and censorship order
Method
How we grade
We only track promises he ran on. To make this list, a pledge has to be load-bearing: repeated on the trail, written into Agenda 47 or the platform, or made a standing rally line. Every politician says something careless into a microphone once. Grading those would be scoring points, not keeping score, so an offhand remark stays out even when the administration later did the opposite of it.
We grade the pledge as it was stated, not as it was later reframed. Executive orders count when they take effect, not when they are signed. Court injunctions are marked Blocked rather than Not Delivered, because the administration acted and someone else stopped it. A pledge delivered at half its promised size is Watered Down, and we say by how much.
We do not grade on intent, effort, or press releases. If the number didn't move, the promise wasn't kept.